Caddies appeal lawsuit dismissal against Tour

Caddies appeal lawsuit dismissal against Tour

Attorneys for a group of caddies made what could be a final stand on Thursday, arguing before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals that a lower court ruling to dismiss the groups lawsuit against the PGA Tour was flawed.A three-judge panel will now decide whether U.S. District judge Vince Chhabria erred when he dismissed the lawsuit in February 2016. The suit was filed by a group of more than 80 caddies claiming, among other things, that the Tour uses them as walking billboards for sponsors.Arthur Miller and Benjamin Major both argued for the caddies that the Tours motion for dismissal should have been converted into a motion for summary judgment, which would have allowed for discovery in what is essentially an anti-trust claim.Central to the caddies argument are the bibs caddies wear during tournament rounds, which they claim prevents them from seeking their own sponsorship opportunities.The very premise of this case is that the caddies have some sort of fundamental right to participate in PGA Tour events on terms and conditions of their own choosing, argued Jeffery Mishkin, an attorney for the Tour. They do not have that fundamental right. The caddies did not create these events, the PGA Tour, as the creator, promoter and organizer of the event, has the right to establish the terms and conditions of participation.The contracts require that the caddies wear a uniform prescribed by the PGA Tour and the host organization.Attorneys for the caddies, however, pointed out that the word bib is never mentioned in what the Tour says is its contract with caddies, which is a form theyre required to sign before each event.The uncertainties and the ambiguities were created by the Tour. They drafted the agreement. They say the bib is the uniform, yet they dont use the word bib in the contract. They include the uniform provision but then they prescribe a dress code, Major argued. They have only relied on tradition, thats the way its only been and thats the way its going to be.At least one judge on the Ninth Circuit panel, Stephen Reinhardt, seemed to agree with the caddies.All the details here about what a caddie should wear [certain color shorts, shoes, etc.], and you fail to mention that [bibs], may make the contract ambiguous, Reinhardt said. You want the caddie to do this, but not the players. It seems odd. It seems people would be influenced more by the players [wearing a bib with tournament advertisements on it].The Tours policy is to not comment on ongoing litigation.The panel did not give any indication when they may rule on the caddies motion.



PGA Tour winner and Annapolis, Maryland, resident Billy Hurley III is running for chairman of the PGA Tour Player Advisory Council. His competition is Jordan Spieth,one of golf's "golden boys." Looks like the campaign is getting dirty.
An architectural excursion across Chicago - mic.com



First, we had the Dustin Johnson Rule. Now, we will probably have the Lexi Thompson Rule. In the USGA's most recent proposed change to the rules of golf, there will be a new rule that states that
The R&A - New Rules of Golf unveiled by The R&A and USGA



English confident in playoff run after just sneaking in Source: The Golf Channel Harris…
English confident in playoff run after just sneaking in



How to Handle an Irate Customer on the Phone. If you work in customer service or own a business, you will occasionally need to take calls from angry customers. How you handle these calls can determine the quality of reviews you receive and
5 Things The Best Managers Do And Don't Do - Forbes



Here's a look at some social media takes, from Tour pros to regular Joes who were watching Tiger vs. Phil in The Match. Social media reaction to The Match: Tiger vs. Phil | Golf Channel Skip to
Social media reaction to The Match: Tiger vs. Phil



Masters: About O'Meara, Woosnam and the tradition of the old guys Sandy Lyle, O'Meara, Larry Mize, Jose Maria Olazabal, Vijay Singh, Mike Weir and Ian Woosnam. I think I took him as my
Vijay Singh Rumors, News & Videos | Yardbarker.com



Bettors are also heading to the windows, eager to place wagers on who will slip into a green jacket come Sunday. And there's plenty of support for Rory McIlroy, who remains a clear favorite at 7/1 at the Westgate Las Vegas SuperBook as he looks to round out the final leg of the career Grand Slam.
McIlroy heads into Masters week as betting favorite
beta.int.sports.yahoo.com/mcilroy-heads-masters-week-betting-091327899.html
Rory McIlroy heads into Masters week as a clear betting favorite as he looks to round out the final leg of the career Grand Slam. More The bettors believe a Grand Slam is on the horizon.
Rory McIlroy now 8-1 betting favorite to win Masters after



Jordan Spieth is using a new Scotty Cameron putter this week at the AT&T Byron Nelson. One week after putter switch, Spieth back to old faithful at Colonial Woods continues to wear metal
Tiger Woods WITB 2018 - National Club Golfer



Rahm co-leads Irish Open, Hend in hunt. AAP. Sunday, 9 July 2017 1:55AM Rory McIlroy could end the week by handing him the trophy after the Spanish star surged into a share of the lead in the Irish Open. Rahm, who outscored playing partner and defending champion McIlroy by 13 shots over the
Jon Rahm tied for Irish Open lead entering final round



LPGA chief of tour operations Heather Daly-Donofrio said the weather that blew through the McKayson New Zealand Women's Open during Sunday's play turn LPGA on Mozo incident: Player safety 'paramount' | Handicaps Network Africa
LPGA's Mozo to pose nude in ESPN 'Body Issue' | Golf Channel



Pat Perez Clarified His Remarks About Tiger Woods' Future, but it Wasn't Necessary but I'm a Tiger fan who wants to see him back playing again. and I'm still getting killed by all
Pat Perez on Tiger Woods: "He knows he can't beat anybody



Eddie Pepperell will tee off in his first Players this week and next month will be his first Masters. Pepperell has been dreaming - quite literally - about his first trip to Augusta National.
Ladder to the 13th tee? Pepperell literally dreaming about



The payouts to everyone up and down the leaderboard are substantial. which was the total the last two years. The news comes after the Players Championship raised its purse to a record $12.5 in
2018 PGA Championship purse, prize money: Payout for each



Round Rock Therapeutic Massage massage services from $35 in Round Rock, TX. Head on over and check out the new website at

Post a Comment

0 Comments